Most flipping advice assumes you’ll drive around town picking things up. But some categories can be flipped almost entirely from home, and video games are one of the best.
Games, consoles and controllers are small, light and easy to ship. They have a huge, active market of collectors and players. And most importantly, their value depends on details most sellers don’t know: which edition it is, which game is in the bundle, whether a tiny accessory is included. That’s where the money is.
These 15 rules apply specifically to video games. Some may carry over to other collectibles, but don’t assume they’ll work for every category. Video games have a combination of shippability, collector demand and price transparency that most items don’t.
Finding the deals
1. Search beyond your own city
If you’re willing to have items shipped, your local area is no longer the limit. Widen your search radius on Marketplace, or browse other cities one at a time. A deal that nobody near you posts this week might be sitting in a city a few hours away. More cities means more listings, and more listings means more mispriced ones.
2. Focus on newly listed items
Underpriced games and consoles don’t last. Collectors, resellers and players all watch the same listings, and a great deal can be gone within the hour. Sort by newest, check often, and set alerts for the consoles and titles you know best. Old listings that are still up are usually still up for a reason.
3. Be the first to message
When a good listing appears, speed beats everything. The first serious message often wins, especially if you’re asking for something extra, like shipping. A clear first message helps: confirm what’s included, make an offer, and say how you’ll pay. “Is this available?” gets ignored. “I’ll pay $X plus shipping through PayPal today” gets answers.
4. Ask sellers to ship
Many sellers list locally and expect a cash meetup. Ask anyway. Most will say no. Some will say yes, especially if they’re tired of no-shows and flaky local buyers. Because video games are small and easy to pack, shipping is a smaller ask than it would be for almost any other category. Treat it as a numbers game: lots of polite asks, a few yeses.
5. Make shipping worth their while
Shipping is extra work for the seller, so make it worth it. Offering slightly more than the asking price, or covering the full shipping cost, can turn a no into a yes. If an item is listed at $40 and you know it sells for $90, offering $50 shipped still leaves you room, and the seller walks away happier than with a local lowball.
Buying safely
6. Always pay with buyer protection
When you’re paying a stranger to mail you something, protect yourself. Use a payment method with purchase protection, such as PayPal Goods & Services, rather than a friends-and-family transfer, cash app or e-transfer. If the item never arrives or isn’t what was described, you have a way to get your money back. The small fee is insurance, and it’s worth it every time.
7. Earn the seller’s trust
Sellers are wary of buyers they can’t meet, and for good reason: Marketplace is full of shipping scams. Make it easy for them to trust you. Keep your messages clear and specific. Use a real profile with a history and ratings. Offer a method of payment they recognize. For a bigger purchase, a quick phone call can settle nerves that text messages can’t. And never ask a seller to do anything that sounds like a scam, like using an unfamiliar shipping service or clicking a link.
Knowing true value
8. Use sold prices, not asking prices
Anyone can list a game for any price. What matters is what people actually paid. On eBay, filter any search to “Sold” items to see real sale prices in similar condition. Check several recent sales, not just one, and compare like with like: loose cartridge versus complete in box, working versus untested. This is the single most important habit in game flipping. Every other rule depends on it.
9. Learn the special editions
Consoles and handhelds often come in limited editions: special colours, game-themed designs, anniversary models. Some sell for several times the price of the standard version. Many sellers have no idea they own one and list it as a regular console. If you can recognize a special edition from a photo, you’ll spot deals other buyers scroll right past.
10. Watch for mislabelled listings
Sellers get model names wrong all the time: mixing up similar handhelds, missing a model variant, or just writing “old game system.” A mislabelled listing doesn’t show up when buyers search for the correct name, which means less competition for you. Read the photos, not just the title.
11. Know the small parts with big value
Some of the most valuable items in a game bundle are the easiest to overlook: wireless receivers, memory cards, specific controllers, original cases and manuals. Small accessories get lost over the years, so complete sets and hard-to-find add-ons can be worth more than you’d expect. When a bundle photo shows a pile of cables and controllers, look closely at every piece.
12. Confirm exactly what the price includes
A photo of three controllers and a price of $15 might mean $15 each or $15 for everything. A console bundle might include the games in the photo, or just the console. Ask before you make an offer. It avoids awkward surprises and sometimes reveals a far better deal than you thought.
Making more from each deal
13. Check the seller’s other listings
When you find one good listing, tap the seller’s profile and see what else they’re selling. People clearing out old games often list them in several posts. Combining them into one purchase gives you a better price, one shipment instead of several, and sometimes a gem the seller didn’t think to feature.
14. Split bundles and sell the pieces
A bundle is often priced as a lump, but buyers pay for specific things. Sell the console with its basic accessories as one listing, the valuable games individually, and the common games grouped together. A bundle bought for under $100 can often bring in far more when it’s sold in the right pieces, because each piece reaches the buyer who wants it most.
15. Don’t dismiss damaged items too quickly
Scratches, a broken shell or a worn button scare off a lot of buyers, and some sellers price damaged items far below what they’re actually worth. If the item still works, or the damage is cosmetic or fixable with a cheap replacement part, there can be a real gap. Just be honest: describe the damage clearly when you resell it.
The hidden costs and honest caveats
Flipping games from home can be very profitable, but the headline numbers people quote are usually revenue or gross profit. Here’s what eats into them:
- Fees. Payment protection fees, marketplace selling fees and eBay final value fees all come out of your margin.
- Shipping costs. You often pay to receive items and charge buyers to send them. Postage varies a lot by country, and in some places it can wipe out the profit on cheaper games. Run the numbers for where you live before assuming a deal works.
- Packing supplies and time. Boxes, bubble wrap, labels and trips to the post office add up.
- Lots of messages, few yeses. For every seller who agrees to ship, many will ignore you or say no.
- Returns and disputes. An item that doesn’t work, or isn’t as described, can cost you the sale and the shipping both ways.
A few rules of conduct keep you out of trouble:
- Test before you sell when you can. If you can’t, label it clearly as “untested” and price it accordingly.
- Disclose reproductions. Reproduction cartridges exist for many popular games. Never sell one as genuine.
- Describe condition honestly. Scratches, missing manuals and worn labels all belong in the listing.
And finally, the big one: this works because you know video games. Without that knowledge, a limited-edition console looks like any other, a valuable cartridge looks like filler, and a missing receiver looks like nothing. The rules only pay off for someone who has learned the niche.
No responses yet